Olive Garden recently started up again in Ontario. This large US chain previously had several locations here, but they all disappeared almost three decades ago. We went to the Ajax location in the RioCan Durham mall at 130 Kingston Road in Ajax, close to the Hwy. 401 Salem Road exit. It’s also directly transit-accessible via the 92 bus from Yorkdale. Beware as there is usually a long delay around the time that this review was written, although that may have changed. They estimated between 1.5 to 2 hours though it was less than an hour. We were put into an addition, formerly an open patio when it was a Wild Wings, which at least had very good heating via hot radiators in the ceiling... when they were on.

Olive Garden is famous for the AYCE unlimited four varieties of soup, salad and breadsticks, but the diner has to choose between soup and salad at the beginning. We both chose soup because there is only one type of salad and the soups looked appealing. (My usual criteria for restaurants that offer only certain items as AYCE is whether one can call it a meal. The soup and breadsticks I think qualify; salad and breadsticks would be a harder sell.) AYCD pop is available, all Pepsi products, and ridiculously overpriced at $5.70. this is about $2 more than anyone else dares charge anywhere. Desserts are also around $12.50 or more for a piece of cake. The wait staff take away the menus after the entrée is ordered, leaving the diner possibly not knowing what soups are available; I made sure to take a picture, but it certainly doesn't encourage ordering of more entrée items. Only the separate dessert menu remains.

Entrées range from $25 to $35. The cheaper entrees are of course mostly based on pasta. I had the stuffed chicken marsala. Mishy had the chicken parmigiana. We both liked the chicken parmigiana although Mishy said we could probably cook it at home to the same quality, but it had a very good marinara sauce and was cooked well at least, and was quite enjoyable. My chicken marsala is served with mashed potatoes with mushroom. Mishy found them to have a maple syrup flavour strangely, and I think this is because she was tasting the reconstituted freeze-dried potatoes from a mix rather than them being made fresh on-premises. The chicken itself and the sauce were quite tasty, and the mushrooms complemented them well and I liked it a lot. Don Alfonso 1890 it isn’t, but it is enjoyable.
Mishy loved the breadstick on first trying it, as it is mildly buttery, warm and savoury like naan, however it becomes too salty on repeated eatings and both of us noticed this.
Chicken and gnocchi soup should have been “and gnoccho” as there was only one of them. It was like a good cream of mushroom soup, but after a while I noticed it's also a bit too salty. Zuppa Toscana was delicious, spicy and very enjoyable with a nice mixture of flavours, which I am surprised of especially considering it contains kale. Spicy. but was not too picante for my liking. Minestrone soup was excellent, with a rich beery flavour, and was full of ingredients, the least watery of all the soups. Pasta e Fagioli soup is like the Italian version of chili with tubetti (ring) pasta and beans and a lovely beef broth flavour, it was delicious, impressively so. The soups were definitely the best part and worthwhile of a higher-end restaurant than a mall chain.
We did not have any dessert and didn’t miss it as I did manage to fill up on the soup and breadsticks, and the desserts are overpriced. The food wasn’t bad with the unlimited soups, the real reason for going fortunately being the best part, but the value isn’t equivalently there. Still, it was nice to try. We might try another location and have the soup/salad/breadsticks-only option.
Rating: 8 - 8.5 / 10 - 1 value adjustment = 7 - 7.5 / 10


